I'm honestly not sure yet.  Haven't booked one at this point, but I'm thinking about the Baymont.  I just know there are several run-of-the-mill hotels right there off 65 at the E-town exit.  Seemed like a good central place not too far out of Louisville to get us on our way the next day.  If you have any suggestions, I'm open to them.

 Can't believe you haven't been to Maker's Mark!  It's beautiful there...I've been 3 times!