Nick,
You hit the nail on the head when you said Haven't Seen You in a Long Time creeped you out. It has always creeped me out. I always skip it when the album plays. And funny people mention Time Brings - I always thought it was a bleak song too, but some people here around me have the opinion it's a beautiful love song.
I guess they are listening to the tune and not the words.
I'd go with Heart of Stone as being alternately sad and beautiful. The verses are gorgeous but the chorus brings you right down. That said, I could listen to that song on repeat forever.
Anne
And when the winds of change begin to blow,
I'll whisper, "You're my lighthouse" in case you didn't know.
Sons of Maxwell
visit my website!:
Anne's Philly Phan Site at http://www.gbsfanatic.com